Wallets are to blockchains what keys are to doors. In fact, they do more than what keys do because they not only provide users with the ability to access the blockchain and keep tabs on their digital assets but also enable them to conduct secure transactions by signing them on the blockchain. Thus, for those familiar with cryptocurrency investments, the importance of protecting your crypto funds in a secure wallet cannot be overemphasized.
It is common for investors to use traditional cryptocurrency wallets that require a signature to transfer assets to a new address. However, this poses a significant risk as private keys are often the target of hacks that can affect both individuals and custodians.
To mitigate this risk, it is important to choose a wallet that requires multiple authorizations for all transactions. There are two main types of wallets that meet this requirement: MultiSig wallets and MPC wallets.
In this article, we will delve into these two wallet types, shedding light on their unique features and differences. Understanding these distinctions is essential for investors seeking the highest level of security for their cryptocurrency holdings.
What Is a MultiSig Wallet?
A MultiSig wallet, short for Multi-Signature wallet, is a cryptocurrency wallet that requires multiple parties, typically two or more private keys or signatures, to carry out transactions. This means that a group of people must collectively give their approval for a transaction to go through.
MultiSig wallets add an extra level of protection, ensuring that no single person has full control over the wallet. This setup is especially beneficial for organizations with substantial funds as it makes it more challenging for unauthorized transactions to occur.
How Does a Multisig Wallet Work?
A MultiSig wallet involves individuals, referred to as “copayers,” who collectively manage the wallet. The required number of signatures for a transaction is typically equal to or fewer than the number of copayers within the wallet.
The process of using a multisig wallet remains the same, regardless of how many key holders are involved. It starts with one user initiating a transaction, providing transaction details, and signing it with their private key. However, the transaction remains pending until all necessary keys have been signed. Once the required number of signatures is entered, the wallet automatically completes the signing process and transfers the funds to the designated address.
Multisig wallets operate without a hierarchy. For instance, if a transaction requires four out of five private keys for validation, it doesn’t matter which specific four signatures complete the transaction. Any combination of four out of the five users can sign the transaction in any order. However, pending transactions will not be completed until all required signatures are provided.
Types of Multisig wallets
- 1-of-2 MultiSig Wallet: This kind of wallet requires two users with the option of confirming it such that the two keys can create a signature. In the 1-of-2 Multisig wallet, you don’t require both keys. Both users can separately manage the funds.
- 2-of-2 MultiSig wallet: This kind of wallet ensures that private keys are on two different devices, making it necessary for transactions to be authorized with both device signatures. The 2-of-2 MultiSig wallet enhances security but poses a risk of fund loss if either of the two devices is compromised.
- 2-of-3 MultiSig Wallet: This type of wallet needs two out of three private keys to approve transactions. Exchanges frequently use it to enhance security for their hot wallets. These 2-of-3 This setup typically involves one key online, another securely stored offline on a dedicated device (paper backup), and a third key stored independently, often by a security company. Even if one private key is compromised, the wallet remains secure due to the additional protection of the offline backup for the hot wallet.
Advantages of Multisig Wallets
- Improved Security: Multisig wallets use multiple signatures from different parties to approve a transaction, reducing the chances of theft or unauthorized access. This approach safeguards against a single point of failure.
- Tailored Approval Options: Multisig wallets offer a “M-of-N” signature scheme, where users can decide the number of signatures (M) needed out of the total participants (N) for approving transactions. This feature allows users to customize the wallet’s security and operational rules according to their preferences.
- Teamwork and Joint Decisions: Multisig wallets encourage collaboration and collective decision-making by necessitating multiple parties to approve transactions. This ensures that everyone has a say in important financial matters.
- Enhanced Control: Multisig wallets allow users to assign distinct roles and responsibilities to various participants. This ensures precise management of digital assets and maintains a clear division of tasks.
Disadvantages of Multisig Wallets
- Increased Complexity: Multisig wallets can be more challenging to set up and handle compared to single-signature wallets. Coordination among multiple parties and their individual private keys adds complexity to the process.
- Requires Technical Skills: Creating and maintaining a multisig wallet might require a more advanced level of technical expertise. Users must be adept at securely handling multiple private keys and orchestrating the signing process with participants.
- Delayed Transactions: In a multisig wallet, transactions may take more time to complete because they involve multiple parties coordinating to gather the needed signatures. This delay can be especially notable when participants are in different time zones.
- Restricted Wallet Compatibility: Multisig features may not be supported by all wallet providers or blockchain platforms, leading to potential issues with support, resources, and compatibility with other tools or services.
What is a Multi-Party Computation (MPC) Wallet?
A Multi-Party Computation Wallet also involves multiple parties, but it uses a specialized system—multi-party computation, hence the name—to generate the private key and create digital signatures required to operate the wallet.
How Does an MPC Wallet Work?
MPC wallets use an m-of-n key share system where a group of users shares key parts to create transaction signatures together. It divides the ownership of a private key among multiple parties.
Those participating in key generation or signing can keep their actions private. Even if an attacker manages to compromise one key shard without permission, they still can’t withdraw funds from an MPC wallet. Hacking an MPC wallet is only possible if all these parties are compromised simultaneously.
This innovative approach aims to minimize the risks associated with lost keys and enhances security by distributing key ownership. Additionally, MPC wallet transactions are more cost-effective as they only require a single signature.
Advantages of MPC Wallets
- Data Privacy: MPC wallets safeguard users’ data privacy by not sharing private info with others or third parties. This means no one can access or manipulate users’ data without their consent or knowledge.
- Decentralization: MPC wallets eliminate the need for a trusted third party to store private keys, as they are shared among multiple parties in the MPC protocol. This minimizes the risk of centralization, corruption, or conspiracy that could threaten the security or accessibility of stored assets.
- Eliminates Single Points of Failure: MPC wallets remove the risk of a single point of failure, which is a concern in other wallet types like single-key, multi-signature, or hardware wallets.
These wallets can be susceptible to problems such as lost or stolen private keys, unavailability of key holders, device malfunctions, or hacking attempts. MPC wallets overcome these challenges by distributing private keys among multiple parties within the MPC protocol. - Accuracy: MPC wallets are known for their accuracy in cryptographic operations. They can handle complex tasks like creating addresses, signing transactions, and verifying signatures precisely and without errors.
- Flexibility: MPC wallets offer flexibility because users can easily include or remove parties from the MPC protocol without disrupting its operation. Users can adapt their security and performance to fit their requirements. For instance, they can enhance security by adding more parties to the protocol.
Disadvantages of MPC Wallets
- Complex Technical Aspects
MPC wallets involve advanced cryptography and distributed computing, which can be challenging to understand and implement correctly. This complexity can result in bugs, errors, or vulnerabilities in the code or protocol, affecting the wallet’s security and performance.
- Compatibility Issues
MPC wallets may face compatibility issues with standard wallets like Ledger and Trezor, as they are not always standardized and are not open-source. These incompatibility issues make MPC wallets less user-friendly for everyday users who prefer widely recognized and compatible wallet solutions.
- Increased Communication Demands
MPC wallets require extensive communication among the parties in the protocol, leading to higher bandwidth usage and potential slowdowns in device networks. This increased communication also makes them more susceptible to network threats, such as denial-of-service (DoS) or man-in-the-middle (MITM) attacks.
MPC vs MultiSig Wallets: How They Differ
Multisig and MPC wallets were created to enhance security and control over digital assets by involving multiple parties in approving transactions. However, they differ in their methods. Here are some key distinctions:
- Blockchain Compatibility
Multisig wallets may not work with every blockchain. In contrast, MPC wallets are more versatile and can operate with most blockchains using the standard EdDSA/ECDSA signing algorithm.
- Privacy and Accountability
Multisig wallets enhance accountability by revealing who signed a transaction. However, this information can be exposed on the blockchain, potentially facilitating malicious actors in tracking and identifying individuals involved in signing multisig transactions.
On the other hand, MPC wallets use an m-of-n key share system where the actual signing process occurs off the chain. This enhances user privacy by recording only the signature on the blockchain.
- Transaction Fees
Multisig wallets require multiple signatures, leading to increased data size and higher transaction fees. In contrast, MPC wallet transactions are more cost-effective as they only need a single signature.
In Conclusion,
Crypto wallet security remains crucial for managing and safeguarding digital assets. The increasing popularity of MPC and Multisig wallets reflects the growing demand for advanced solutions to ensure the safety of crypto holdings.
It’s important to acknowledge that the responsibility for securing assets ultimately lies with the individual users. One of the best things you can do is to stay informed about the latest and most effective practices to enhance your protection against cryptocurrency theft.
Disclaimer: This article is intended solely for informational purposes only and should not be considered trading or investment advice. Nothing herein should be construed as financial, legal, or tax advice. Trading or investing in cryptocurrencies carries a considerable risk of financial loss. Always conduct due diligence.
If you would like to read more articles like this, visit DeFi Planet and follow us on Twitter, LinkedIn, Facebook, and Instagram, and CoinMarketCap Community.
“Take control of your crypto portfolio with MARKETS PRO, DeFi Planet’s suite of analytics tools.”
